Comparative Study between Jordanian and Chinese Mediation Systems

来源 :兰州大学 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:proudboy_linux_wzh
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
Mediation is one form of art, including intuition, subtlety, and vision.Furthermore it is also a skill to deal with transferable tools, definable tasks, and manage challenges.The purposeof the mediators toolkit series is to help mediators learn from each other by filtrate from their experience useful lessonsabout the used tools, the tasks they must perform, and the challenges they must overcome.  Mediation is a most advanced and civilized form of dispute resolution mechanism.Now, it is accepted by all that mediation facilitates disputing parties to open and improve dialogue between them and gives an opportunity to claims self-analysis.The mediation is being accepted as an approach of dispute resolution.Now,it is resulting in a quicker cases clearance and isbeing to bring amicable solutions of disputes through a dialogue between the dispute parties with assistance of neutral mediator,who creates a peaceful atmosphere for the disputant parties to work towards a positive solution of their choice.Mediation is a tool for personal empowerment for autonomy.  Though, it is felt that the process of mediation is growing rapidly.Still, it is experienced that the use of the mediation for settlement of disputes is very much limited according to expected growth.There are challenges and obstacles in using the techniques of mediation for settlement of disputes in the mediation implementation.  Moreover, the importance of mediator in the entire processcannot be ignored.The techniques or standards of mediation practice adopted by the mediators during negotiation between the parties and for dispute settlement have a pivotal role to play.It is said that mediation is the best way of imparting justice through the self determination of the parties.  The present article attempts to answer questions by looking at the overall predominance of mediation in Jordan and Chinain light of its specific historical,cultural and political background,and how it impacts the contemporary practice of integrating mediation into arbitration.First,the study discusses mediation in general and evaluates the reasons for its continued existence in the Chinese and Jordanian systems.Second,the study discusses the Chinese way of integrating mediation into arbitral proceedings and explores the history, practice and benefits of such a combination.Finally,this study speculates as to  how the Chinese model might be useful in contributing to create a practice in Jordan. In this study,we reflect on the Challenges that can beset mediation,particularly at this early stageof the new reform effort in Jordan.  First,is the challenge of knowledge and information about the reform, how does the  ordinary citizen get to know about this reform measure, and toadopt the details of its processes,procedure and practice?To address that particular challenge,Jordan and China did design acomprehensive strategy for Outreach-aimed at publicizing the judicial reforms now taking place in the Country-including, in particular, the introduction of the Court Annexed Mediation.The strategy has used, and continues to use the radios,the TV,the print media and other avenues of transmitting the necessary information and knowledge to the public.  Second,is the challenge of dealing with the Transition-namely grafting the new Mediation branch, onto the existing of litigation? In China from the outset,the design provided for a two-tier track.All new cases those filed in the High Court after the commencement of Court-Annexed Mediation would automatically follow the Mediation track-in accordance with the applicable procedural requirements for triggering the mediation process.On the other hand,the timing for referral of all casesfiled prior to the commencement of Court-Annexed Mediation is left to the discretion of the allocated/presiding Judge.This was intended,among other things, to minimize swamping either track with an avalanche of caseload: namely,to take the new medicine in manageable doses,so to speak.  This study first focuses on the significance of mediation on resolving the disputes compared with other ways of dispute settlement and a comprehensive study of elements of mediation.  The study also explores the process of mediation, its procedures and the partiesrole in securing a successful mediation.It discusses the challenges that confront the mediation  and the suggestions for overcoming such challenges.I conclude the study with the most significant results incurred upon mediation process and summarize a set of recommendations in the end of my dissertation.  The methodology that is followed in this study is based on the combination of the descriptive approaches which reveals the legal provisions and jurisprudence opinions related to mediation and analytical method based on the analysis of texts andreasoning of the results.  The study concludes that mediation is a voluntary operation aimed to achieve the win win benefits of both parties of dispute.Mediation emerges and grows on the ground of basic principles such as voluntary decision, self-option of the dispute parties,neutrality, unbiased mediator and confidentiality.  This study has shown that despite the efforts in both China and Jordan to improve the use of mediation,the current mediation systems in both places are still facing many problems, which undermine the quality and effectiveness of mediation as a powerful dispute resolution tool.Having said that, by learningand borrowing the advantages from each others mediation system,they could both be effectively rectified.Learning from Jordan,China should separate mediation from adjudication and also enable peoples mediators to charge for their services.On the other hand, Jordan should actively consider adopting thecourt-performedapproach implemented in China in hopes of gaining the publics confidence and increasing the likelihood that disputants use mediation more cooperatively and genuinely.Once these reforms are in place,the quality of mediation will improveand mediation will assume an even more significant role in theresolution of disputes.
其他文献
<正>中国是世界猕猴桃生产大国,猕猴桃栽培面积从2010年的106万亩,迅速发展到2015年的260万亩,产量、面积均居世界第一。陕西是我国猕猴桃生产大省,面积、产量位居国内首位、
受应试教育和传统教材内容的限制,当前教师在开展教学活动的时候一般会将知识传授作为基本内容,忽视了对问题意识的培养。由此导致现阶段的大多数小学生在数学学习中不敢提问
期刊
本文主要考察了外交政策分析中个人层次发挥作用的变量,具体来说,研究涉及外交决策过程中领导人的心理和“小集团”动态的影响。毫无疑问,舀际社会和人类生活中的其他很多问
随着民族旅游的不断发展和民众闲暇时间的增加,旅游成为人们生活的时尚消费,特别是民族村寨旅游成为游客自主旅游的首选,其中,民族村寨演艺产品倍受游客青睐。民族村寨演艺是随着
在民法慈母般的眼睛里,每一个个人就是整个的国家。然而由于征收制度的存在,公权力却具备了强制取得私人财产的合法的依据。此时,征收的前提—公共利益的界定,成为了决定征收行为