论文部分内容阅读
2005年,本刊第9期刊发了刘锦森同志的文章,题为“对报批法规应进行合理性审查”。作者认为:“对报批的地方性法规仅仅进行合法性审查是不够的,还是对其进行合理性审查。”刘书亮同志读了这篇文章后认为:“审批机关对报批法规进行合法性审查,实质上就是对其进行合理性审查,是更具有现实意义的合理性审查,不能把合法性审查与合理性审查对立起来。”他提出,合法性审查与合理性审查构不成一对矛盾,不具有对立统一关系,“合理性审查”的提法值得商榷。
In 2005, No. 9 of this issue published an article entitled Comrade Liu Jinsen, entitled “The approval of laws and regulations should be rationally reviewed.” The author thinks: “It is not enough to review the legitimacy of the local laws and regulations for approval only, or to conduct a reasonable review of them.” After reading this article, Comrade Liu Shu-liang said: “The examination and approval authority examines the legitimacy of the examination and approval rules, It is a more reasonable review of legitimacy to conduct a reasonable review of the case, and the legal review can not be opposed to a reasonable review. ”He proposed that there should be no contradiction between the review of legitimacy and the examination of rationality, Opposition and unity, the “reasonable review” of the formulation is questionable.