论文部分内容阅读
打官司总会有输有赢,但对于艺术品拍卖领域所涉及的私人信札案件而言,输或者赢,其实都是一种失败。近日,持续两年之久的周作人之孙周吉宜状告国内某知名拍卖公司之“周作人手稿”一案终于有了结果。北京市东城区法院日前宣判:“无权占有不动产或者动产的,权利人可以要求返还原物。现原告、被告均认可诉争的手稿已经拍卖,被告已不占有该诉争手稿,对于原稿要求被告返还诉争手稿的请求,缺乏事实和法律依据,本院不予支持。对于原告要求确认涉案手稿的所有权等相关权益属于原告的请求,缺乏事实根据,
Lawsuits will always win or lose, but losing or winning is actually a failure for private letters and cases involved in the art auction. Recently, Zhou Jiyi, a great man of Zhou Zuoren who lasted for two years, sued the well-known auction house of Zhou for ”Zhou Zuoren’s Manuscript“ for its success finally. Beijing Dongcheng District Court recently sentenced: ”the right holders can not claim possession of real estate or movable property, the obligee can request the return of the original .At the plaintiff, the defendants have recognized the manuscript of the dispute has been auctioned, the defendant is no longer possession of the draft manuscript for the prosecution The request of the defendant to return the draft manuscript for lack of factual and legal basis is not supported by this court.For the plaintiff’s request to confirm the ownership of the manuscript in question and other related rights belong to the plaintiff’s request and lack of factual basis,