The Concepts of “Corridor” and “Channel”:Anthropological Reconstruction of Area Studies in Southwest

来源 :民族学刊 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:luluwm
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
The historically complicated eth-nic migration and cultural interaction , as well as present day multi -ethnic interactive symbiosis in the “corridors” and “channels” of Southwest China constitutes a great challenge to the tradition-al “taxonomic-style” ethnic research and modern“mosaic-style” understanding of the region . Mo-reover , it also stimulates those in Southwest stud-ies to pay more attention to a regional model of“cross-cutting” and integration . Different from the “single ethnic group” research model , area studies in Southwest China emphasizes the break-down of administrative divisions , and the tran-scendence of ethnic boundaries .It attempts to ex-plore the feature of mobility and structure of rela-tionships contained in the “Southwest” itself based on the characteristics of the ethnic “corri-dors” and migration “channels” in this region. The rise of the topics , such as the zangyi zoulang ( Tibetan-Yi Corridor ) , the xinan sichou zhilu ( Southwest Silk Road ) , and the chama gudao ( the Ancient Tea Caravan Road ) in current aca-demic circles is pushing areas studies in Southwest China to a higher academic level and theoretical cognition .Based on a review and forecast of this academic trend , this article tries to give some thoughts on the future development , and possible breakthroughs , of contemporary anthropological studies in Southwest China from the aspects of re-search subjects , problem consciousness , and methodology . 1.The “ Corridor” Doctrine: A Model ofArea Studies in Southwest ChinaSince the 1980s, the direction of SouthwestStudies could be summarized into two aspects : 1)the creation of a comprehensive area studies pattern,for instances, the emergence of the researchon the “Tibetan-Yi Corridor”, and “Ancient TeaCaravan Route”; 2) the gradual development ofspecial research on a single ethnic group, for instance,the founding of various associations whichaimto study a specific ethnic group, such as theTibetology Association, Association for the YiStudies, and the Association for the Miao Studies.While the former takes regional socio-cultural characteristicsas its research theme, and represents akind of awakening of awareness of academic disciplines.The latter takes the ethnic group as an objectof study, which represents a kind of ethnicself-consciousness.Fei Xiaotong considered thatethnic studies which focus on a single group doubtlesslybring many theoretical dilemmas and issuesof reality. Therefore, around 1980 he proposedthe concept of minzu zoulang (ethnic corridor),and tried to break the limitations of “single ethnicgroup” study by using an approach of area studiesin order to manage the various problems related tocontemporary China′s ethnic classification.Basedon the investigation and summary of ethnic migrationsin Chinese history, Fei also proposed threecorridors concerning China′s ethnic migration andethnic cultural exchange: (i) the Northwest Corridor;(ii) the Tibetan-Yi Corridor; and (iii)the Nanling Corridor.Therefore, the formation of minzu zoulang doctrine has an important meaningfor the concept of “The pattern of diversity in unityof the Chinese nation”, and it also reveals thematuration of a regional vision in ethnic anthropological studies in China. Actually, the usage of “ corridor ” and“channel” to summarize geographical characteristicsand ethnic mobility in Southwest China also re -flected an academic consensus in early academiccircles both home and abroad.Since the reconstructionof ethnology and anthropology in 1980,Southwest Studies have displayed its characteristicsof “area studies”.This is seen especially in thefoundation of the “Southwest China Ethnology andAnthropology Society ” in 1981, which furthermarked the opening of a regional vision and practicein the Southwest Studies.Driven by the society,the academic forces of Southwest Studies havebeen integrated and organized; and a series ofspecial investigations based upon characteristics ofarea studies, such as “watershed”, “corridor”or “channel”, have been conducted.The meaning of restarting Southwest researchin contemporary anthropology by using the conceptsof “ethnic corridor”, “mountain-water channel”fits with what Li Shaoming stressed when summari -zing the “regional paradigm” of Tibetan-Yi Corridorstudies.He said: “It provides a regional,dynamic and interrelated research perspective toobserve ethnic interaction and cultural influence indifferent historical periods by taking the Tibetan-Yicorridor as a totality.On this basis, we can understandwhy the Chinese nation is a totality of diversityin unity, and explains the specific reasonsfor the formation and development of the Chinesenation.” This also represents a significant contributionmade by area studies in Southwest China tothe development of the discipline in contemporarysocial sciences.It not only overcomes the past disadvantagesof administrative divisions and fragmentationin the ethnic studies, but also deeply revealsthe historical fact of multi-ethnic interactivesymbiosis in Southwest China, as a migrationchannel and ethnic corridor.Moreover, it alsostimulates real academic dialogue with two big anthropologicalresearch paradigms in China, i.e.“rural community research” and “single ethnicstudies”. 2.“Channel” Studies: an Expansion of AreaStudies in Southwest China After the “reform and open policy”, threeresearch paradigms, including “ area studies”,the “ ethnicity model ” and the “ transnationalmodel” have gradually appeared in SouthwestStudies.While the latter two research paradigmshave obvious characteristics of individualism and atrend towards world systematism, and represent apassive academic reflection of modern ideology andpolitical economic structure, the paradigm of “areastudies” is much closer to social and historicalreality, and its practice has a strong sense of disciplinaryawareness.As an important tradition andsign of this academic field, the paradigm of “areastudies” in Southwest Studies is just such an innovativeresearch paradigm which can break throughadministrative and ethnic boundaries, and is constructedfrom the regional characteristics of ethnology.The Southwest, as an ethnic corridor andmigration channel filled with mobility and interaction,has been a concern by more and more scholars.The “channel” concept of Southwest Chinahas broken down the bias that this region is“closed and isolated”.Different from the doctrineof “corridor”, which pays more attention on themigration mobility and cultural contacts, the conceptof “channel” studies pays more attention tothe commercial mobility and mutual transmission ofcivilizations.Trans-cultural trade and trans-civilizationpolitical interaction has become the focus ofSouthwest studies in recent years, especially topicsconcerning tea, horse, salt, wood, etc.Therelationship of the Southwest to its surrounding civ -ilizations, and the connections within the regionhas become a new hot topic related to “channel”studies in recent years. Since 2005, the anthropological research relatedto “ courier routes ” has emerged inGuizhou.Different from a commercial route, the“courier route” itself was a product of the state,and was an important measure for understandinghow the “empire state” opened up and managedits frontier areas.Compared with the study of“commercial routes” in Yunnan, the investigationof the “courier routes” in Guizhou not only concernsthe “external and internal” interactions amongvarious ethnic groups, it also stresses a“top-down” connection between the state and thelocal region, which displayed the kinds of effortsmade by the state to deepen and expand the areastudies in Southwest China. The construction of modern highways is noteworthyduring the process of modernization inSouthwest China.The change in social relationsand cultural conceptions which resulted from theconstruction of modern roads is just one topicwhich is concerned in the anthropological study ofroads.Road construction in Southwest China isclosely related to the “ nationalization ” and“ marketization ” of modernity. Therefore, theroad connects not only geographical space , but alsoconnects the local system with the entire worldsystem.To a certain degree, the introduction ofthe study of roads makes “channel studies” inSouthwest China closer to the contemporaryscenes, and also broadens “problem consciousness”in area studies in Southwest China.However,neither traditional “channel ” studies nor therise of the new study of roads regional integrationand ethnic interaction are the main topic for thediscussion.These studies are complementary tothe doctrine of “corridor”, and further expandthe regional model of Southwest research . 3.“ Relationship ” Investigation: The Essenceof Area Studies in Southwest China In current anthropological circles, one groupof scholars have stepped into a so-called “isolated”mode, and have become specialists on thestudy of a particular “tribe”, or “community”;and the other group have left the “practical” regions,and become politicians who care about the“state” and “ world system”.Therefore, whatanthropology in Southwest Studies needs to consid -er is how to break through the limitations and dilemmascreated by the core conceptions in contemporarysocial sciences, such as “society”, “culture”,“nationality” and “state” etc.on thetheoretical purport and methodology.The rise of“area studies” is a supplement and correction tothe ethnic classification of “ethnic model”, andnational boundaries of “transnational model”.Inrecent years, in various academic discussions on Southwest studies, scholars have been trying tounderstand the regional cultural features of South -west China from the angle of cultural relations;Professor Wang Mingming specifically presents akind of Southwest Studies concerning “RelationalismEthnology”. The “regional model”, which is based onthe doctrine of “corridor” and “channel” studies,takes interaction and mobility as the focus ofthe research, and interprets the socio-cultural relationshipstructure in China in depth.This isgood for China′s anthropology to obtain a worldschema which is in more accord with Chinese historicaland cultural experiences, and also is helpfulfor researchers to obtain real cultural consciousnessand cognitive subjectivity.Anthropologicalstudies in Southwest China must be conducted froma large “regional” perspective, and must searchfor problem consciousness of Southwest Studies in arelationship pattern.In this way it can avoid themodern narrative of “ethnicity”, transcend thosequestions such as “ethnic identity”, and finallyreturn to local social-historical reality and the morphologicaltraits of humanities, deepen the indepthunderstanding of Southwest China , havemore in-depth theoretical dialogues, and raise realquestions to modern social science itself.
其他文献
目前,牡丹江有关噪音扰民的投诉在不断增加,超标噪音污染,严重影响着老百姓的生活质量和精神质量,已经成为牡丹江一个重要的城市问题。只有掌握牡丹江市区声环境质量状况并分析其特征,才能有针对性地提出治理意见,使城市居民,不受噪音的"迫害",使他们能够在紧张的工作之余得以良好的修整。
目的 了解自贡市大安区5岁以下儿童死亡的主要原因及相关因素,并提出相应的干预措施.方法 对2001-2010年大安区妇幼卫生监测点上报的417 例5岁以下儿童死亡监测数据及死因构
介绍了一起服用迭氮钠中毒死亡的案件,实验室中利用离子色谱法,对现场所提取的检材进行检验分析,同时考察了N3-浓度对其保留时间的影响。实验结果表明,运用离子色谱法,采用合
盲元是影响非制冷红外焦平面阵列(IRFPA)成像质量的因素之一。在对非制冷红外焦平面阵列中盲元的响应特性分析的基础上,提出一种基于双阈值快速迭代盲元检测算法。该算法基于
流形数据的查询需要使用流形的嵌入表示,因此查询流形数据需要访问大量的样本数据.提出一种选择标注分层流形学习算法,选择出的标注点集用来帮助查找流形数据.首先采用自适应
针对聚类分析在处理任意形状、任意密度和具有一定结构特征的数据集时存在的不足,首先在数据空间中建立离散拓扑流形,通过在此结构上定义邻域密度相似性和邻域密度变化光滑性
采用溶胶-凝胶法制备了含有吸收性杂质和非吸收性杂质的SiO2增透膜,采用波长为1 064 nm的激光对其进行了小光斑激光预处理,对比研究了预处理前后的激光损伤差异,研究表明:激
一是严格栽植标准。苗木规格和品种突出景观性,除常规品种外,引进香花槐、紫珠等大规格苗木。二是强化后期管护。重点抓好树木栽后管护工作,建立树木管养登记表,实施全过程台账式
近日,安徽郎溪县水产站“改造低洼田养殖克氏原螯虾成虾的方法”喜获国家发明专利授权。
有人说,成熟是人的年龄达到一定阶段,身体形态和人体机能趋近完善的表现,是人的智力、情绪、社会适应性及心理达到的较佳的状态。其实,一个人成熟与否,并非决定于年龄的大小和社会