读了《地质科学》1977年第2期和1978年第1期先后刊载的《地球化学位》和《地球化学位守恒》两文后,发现其中存在未被作者察觉的数学疏失,致使推出的大量关系式不能成立,由此作出的地质推论也就缺乏基础。我们认为有必要提出来加以讨论。《地球化学位》一文根据熟知的热力学关系式(16),稍经演变,导出文中作为假设提出的关键方程 After reading “Geochemical Degree” and “Geochemical Degree Conservation” published two times in Geological Science, No. 2, 1977 and No. 1, 1978, it was found that there was a math omission which was not detected by the author, resulting in the introduction of A large number of relations can not be established, and the resulting geological deduction also lacks foundation. We think it necessary to raise it for discussion. According to the well-known thermodynamic relationship (16), the term “geochemistry” has been slightly modified to derive the key equation presented as a hypothesis