Reconciling Local and Global Agendas in Sustainable Development: Participatory Research with Indigen

来源 :Journal of Mountain Science | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:sb0077
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
This paper discusses participatory research in the Andes and presents a case study in Cotacachi, Ecuador, where sustainability scientists and indigenous people seek common ground in their respective but drastically different research and social agendas. Participatory research based on Andean experiences pre-dated and inspired much of the later international movement in agriculture, health, and conservation. Andean communities have a long history in demanding that outsiders address the needs of the community as a condition for carrying out scientific or applied activities. What an Andean community, however, sees as relevant may or may not be within the rubric of ‘participatory research’ as it is practiced throughout much of the world. In fact, overzealous participatory researchers are just as bothersome as their predecessors bearing long questionnaires. More important to Andean people is an equitable relationship with researchers and developers in which exchanges of value are made. A distinction between ‘enriching’ and ‘extractive’ research is drawn. In the case of the SANREM project in Cotacachi, Ecuador, scientists carried out enriching research activities of interest to local people as a wayto generate social capital for conducting basic research which does not have an obvious, immediate local benefit. The requested research did not have a conventional participatory methodology but provided valuable products (educational opportunity, germplasm, community visualization tools, and information) to the indigenous community in exchange for time and resources to conduct research on more basic natural resource questions. We argue that in the Andean context the key to reconciling the needs of scientists and of local needs is seeking new forms of equitable collaboration which reach beyond the present and now somewhat tired discourse of ‘participation’. This paper engaging participatory research in the Andes and presents a case study in Cotacachi, Ecuador, where sustainability scientists and indigenous people seek common ground in their respective but drastically different research and social agendas. Participatory research based on Andean experiences pre-dated and inspired much of the later international movement in agriculture, health, and conservation. Andean communities have a long history in demanding that outsiders address the needs of the community as a condition for carrying out scientific or applied activities. Any an Andean community, however, sees as relevant may or may not be within the rubric of ’participatory research’ as ​​it is practiced throughout much of the world. In fact, overzealous participatory researchers are just as bothersome as their predecessors bearing long questionnaires. More important to Andean people is an equitable relationship with researchers and developers in which exchanges of value are made. A distinction between ’enriching’ and ’extractive’ research is drawn. In the case of the SANREM project in Cotacachi, Ecuador, scientists carried out enriching research activities of interest to local people as a way to generate social capital for conducting basic research which does not the requested research did not have a conventional participatory methodology but provided valuable products (educational opportunity, germplasm, community visualization tools, and information) to the indigenous community in exchange for time and resources to conduct research on more basic natural resource questions. We argue that in the Andean context the key to reconciling the needs of scientists and of local needs is seeking new forms of equitable collaboration which reach beyond the present and now somewhat tired discourse of ’participation’.
其他文献
为探究吕家坨井田地质构造格局,根据钻孔勘探资料,采用分形理论和趋势面分析方法,研究了井田7
“我到现在,一直都能听到她的歌声。真的!她的歌声,总是在我心里不断出现,就像一堆记忆的散片,说不定是哪一片会突如其来地闪现在我的脑海里,那样真切;经常出现的,是她的琴声,那优美的、有时又断断续续的、当时我都叫不上名字的琴声。”  “你还记得吗?当时,那一个很大的仓库,堆放着很多纸板箱的纸板,高高的就像山一样遮蔽着仓库顶棚的灯光,你走在里面,脚步会发出一种空旷的声音,空气又带有一种甜甜的纸制品的香气
期刊
为探究吕家坨井田地质构造格局,根据钻孔勘探资料,采用分形理论和趋势面分析方法,研究了井田7
服装设计的基础就是服装人体造型.立体构成的学习就是为了启发学生对形体的想象及感受,强化空间立体概念,培养他们创造新形态的能力和实践制作能力.立体构成可以有效地激发学
老一代学者曾经谈到的“去蔽”思想,应该是我们今天“补课”的一项重要内容。潘光旦先生从“去蔽”的角度来强调人文学科在社会发展中的重要性,在今天仍然很有启发意义。社会
期刊
本文以居住空间的情感设计为主要线索,本着“以人为本”的设计理念,从情感设计对于住宅空间品质提升的意义及住宅空间的情感表达的方法两个方面来探讨如何满足人们对室内环境
本文回顾我国文化主权建设的历程,辨析国家文化主权的特征、内涵,提出建设国家文化主权的近期任务,强调建设国家文化主权的重要意义:维护国家文化安全,并进而维护国家主权与
我轻轻念叨春天  公园路桃花便开了,李花白了,紫荆花  半红半白。燃烧着一条街  更多花骨朵,像待嫁的新娘集結  有尖叫,有惊叹,莺声燕语  她们赏花,其实是惺惺相惜  是一朵欣赏另一朵  我也在赏花。没人留意落花  没人在意,不起眼的中年男人  头上的小雪。  秋分  日历说,今日秋分  南国依旧花红柳绿  窗外,秋阳下  树叶呈老相,我发现  一片叶子抖了抖。  打个电话回老家,老妈叹着气说 
期刊
为探究吕家坨井田地质构造格局,根据钻孔勘探资料,采用分形理论和趋势面分析方法,研究了井田7