有关形式逻辑与学术规范的讨论,在中国学术界已经持续了相当长的一段时间。我以为,这场大讨论到目前为止达成的共识有这样几点:第一,“学术规范”不是万能的,但没有学术规范则是万万不能的;第二,不同的学科、不同的国家有不同的学术传统和规范,不可能强求一律,但重要的是要有规范,即“有法可依”;第三,学术规范是一套约定俗成的游戏规则,所谓 The discussion of formal logic and academic norms has been taking place in academia in China for quite some time. In my opinion, the consensus reached so far in this major discussion is as follows: First, “academic norms ” is not a panacea, but no academic norms are absolutely impossible; second, different disciplines and different Of countries have different academic traditions and norms and can not impose any requirement on one’s own. However, it is important that there is a norm, that is, “there are laws and regulations to follow.” Third, academic norms are a set of conventionally established rules of the game.