《艺苑》1982年第二期所刊鄂允文同志的《关于<阿炳事考一二及其他>的商榷》一文,因其谬误甚多与史料不符,为澄清问题,还事实本源,再进行一些商榷。大量史料证明:阿炳从未被“议出”过道观阿炳有没有被“逐出”、“议出”或“排挤出”过道观?大量史料证明:阿炳从未被“逐出”或“议出”过道观。关于这个问题,沈洽同志的《阿炳事考一二及其他》一文,运用充分的、确凿的资 In his article “Discussing Arguments for A Bing and Other Questions” written by E Yun-wen in the second issue of Yiyuan in 1982, because of many fallacies that are inconsistent with the historical data, in order to clarify the issue, For some discussion. A large number of historical data proves that Bing has never been denied “proposing” or “aisle” of aisles. Are there any excuses that A Bing has been “expelled”, “negotiated” or “excluded?” Bing has never been “expelled” or “negotiated” aisles. With regard to this issue, Comrade Shen Qia’s article entitled “A Bing Shi Yi Er and Other” made full and definite contributions