论文部分内容阅读
李青淼《唐代前期都督府探讨》一文存在逻辑思维不清晰、史料运用不适当、以及先入为主之臆断诸原因,导致其关于唐前期都督府职掌的四项立论,即所谓“唐初是都督府军政时期”、贞观元年后内地“一些都督府职能从军政到民政的转变”、贞观元年后“边境地区都督府仍旧保持其很强的军事职能”、“都督府在从军政向民政转变过程中其等级由统州降至与州同级”四个观点,并不符合历史实际,也并不存在。本文旨在透过相关学术问题的讨论达成学术认识的科学性。
Li Qing-miao, “Discussion on Dudu Fu in the Early Tang Dynasty,” an article with unclear logical thinking, improper use of historical data, and presumed assumptions of various reasons led to its four prepositions about the government of Dudu Fu in the early Tang Dynasty, the so-called During the period of the military administration, the first year after the Zhenguan monarchy changed its functions of military affairs to civil affairs in the Mainland after the first year of Zhenguan. In the first year of Zhenguan, the government in the border area still maintained its strong military function. In the process of transforming from military and civilian affairs to civil affairs, its rank was reduced to the same level as that of the state by the state system. "These four views do not conform to historical facts and do not exist. This article aims to reach a scientific understanding of academic understanding through discussion of relevant academic issues.