论文部分内容阅读
司法裁判结果确定性与司法裁判活动维护正义的现实功能之间存在着逻辑上的必然联系,因此对于司法裁判结果的确定性进行分析将有助于透视司法裁判各个主导因素的内在结构,从而更好的履行其维护正义的职能。但这一解构过程中似乎存在着一些难以用具象标准来阐释的司法环节,如自由裁量权的行使。因此本文尝试以德沃金的正确答案命题为坐标,构筑一个更易于直观理解的分析体系。
There is a logical and necessary relationship between the certainty of the outcome of judicial adjudication and the actual function of judicial adjudication to defend justice. Therefore, the analysis of the certainty of the outcome of judicial adjudication will help to reveal the inherent structure of the dominant factors of judicial adjudication. Good performance of its function of maintaining justice. However, there seems to be some judicial links in this process of deconstruction that are difficult to be explained by figurative standards, such as the exercise of discretion. Therefore, this paper attempts to use Dworkin’s correct answer proposition as coordinates, to build a more intuitive understanding of the analysis system.