自首轮新方志编修开展以来,省志编纂经验总结和理论探讨与市县志相比,相对薄弱,对省志编纂工作中的问题缺乏研究和分析。作者从对两轮《山东省志.工商行政管理志》的分析和比较中,看到第二轮《山东省志.工商行政管理志》在质量提高的前提下,存在的优长与不足。指出目前省志编纂工作中的优势在于依托政府部门,行政力度大,部门业务熟,工作档案多,但也极易出现部门志的倾向和缺乏大历史观。并提出如果对于某一事业作为一个行业认识的视野再拓宽一些,省志的立意将更高,记述的深度将更深。 Since the first round of compilation of the new Local Records has been carried out, provincial compilation of experience summary and theoretical discussion compared with the city and county, relatively weak, lack of research and analysis of the provincial compilation of work. From the analysis and comparison of two “Shandong Provincial Records. Administration for Industry and Commerce”, the author sees the advantages and disadvantages existing in the second round of “Administration of Industry and Commerce Administration of Shandong Province” on the premise of quality improvement. It points out that at present the advantage in compiling the provincial records lies in relying on the government departments, having great administrative work, being familiar with the business operations and having a large number of working files. However, it is also prone to the tendency of departmental ambitions and the lack of a grand historical view. And proposed that if a business as an industry to broaden the horizons of vision, provincial conception will be higher, the narrative depth will be deeper.