论文部分内容阅读
聂树斌案的再审改判是近年来案件纠错的一个巨大成就,冤案的形成究其原因来说刑事归责原则未得到严格使用,通过原审、再审判决对比可以发现在当时的司法背景下过分追求司法效率忽视人权、正义现象十分突出。通过与“辛普森案”的对比,过分追求效率反而会导致不效率,在纠错、国家赔偿以及社会效果方面都会耗费巨大的成本。因此要严格法律责任规则原则的适用。
The trial and adjudication of Nie Shubin case is a great achievement in the correction of cases in recent years. The formation of injustice case is not strictly used because of the principle of criminal responsibility. Through the comparison of the original trial and the retrial, we can find that in the current judicial background, excessive pursuit of justice Efficiency ignores human rights and justice is very prominent. By contrasting with the Simpson case, over-pursuing efficiency on the contrary leads to inefficiency and costs a great deal in error correction, state compensation and social effects. Therefore, we must strictly apply the principle of legal liability.