全国政协文史资料研究委员会编辑、中华书局出版的《文史资料选辑》第八辑,刊登了唐永良先生撰写的《商震历史概述》一文,文中有下面一段:“一九三八年春,商部放弃黄河以北,撤退到黄河南岸,沿河布防。五月,日寇土肥原部队由考城以北偷渡黄河向开封挺进。国民党中央军薛岳 The eighth series of “Selection of Historical Materials” published by Zhonghua Book Company published by the editor in chief of Literature and Historical Data Research Committee of the CPPCC, published in “An Overview of the History of Shangzhen” by Mr. Tang Yongliang in the following passage: "In the spring of 1938, In the north of the Yellow River, retreated to the south bank of the Yellow River and deployed troops along the river. In May, the native of Tianjin made a move to Kaifeng by stealing the Yellow River from north of the city of Kaohsiung.