Time to Tackle Child Abuse

来源 :Beijing Review | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:tuantuan731
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
  
  Child abuse has recently been a topic of widespread discussion in China. Two scandals that occurred this year have sparked renewed calls for legislation.
  In one instance, a picture posted on the Internet showed a young female teacher holding up a student by his ears with his feet about 10 cm off the ground in a kindergarten class in Wenling, east China’s Zhejiang Province.
  The teacher smiled as the boy cried out in pain. The woman was later fired and detained by police, but then set free. The boy is still at home recovering from his injuries.“He is afraid of going to school and has nightmares,” his mother said.
  In another case, a kindergarten girl in north China’s Shanxi Province was slapped in the face repeatedly for more than 10 minutes by her teacher because the child failed to answer a mathematics question. The teacher was detained for 15 days.
  People in legal circles say that China’s current Criminal Law states that abuse is applicable only among family members. Typically, suspects of child abuse in kindergartens are put under administrative detention for up to 15 days, meaning they will not face criminal charges.
  There are many laws against child abuse in China. For example, the Constitution and laws on compulsory education and protection of minors contain items regarding child abuse. But the Criminal Law has no specific crime relating to child abuse. The definition of child abuse is unclear.
  Whether or not child abuse should be taken as a crime has been heatedly discussed. The following are excerpts of some opinions.
  Ling Ling (www.shangdu.com): The child abuse incident in Wenling is not an isolated case. In just two years, we have seen more than 10 child abuse cases in kindergartens. Methods ranging in severity from the inappropriate to the horrible are employed to torture or harass children.
  However, no articles or clauses in China’s current Criminal Law are appli- cable to these child abuse suspects. The problem is that although some abuse is not physical, which provides evidence for prosecution, but rather mental, causing lifelong psychological damage. Nevertheless, those who impose these injuries won’t be punished by the Criminal Law, but will only be put under administrative detention. Such kind of punishment will do little to deter these suspects and thus is unlikely to prevent potential child abuse scandals in the future.
  Putting forward legislation on child abuse and punishing those found guilty should have already been addressed. Recent years have seen many changes and much improvement in China’s legal system. Emergencies and scandals often spur such advances in legislation. When the current laws are no longer able to properly address new issues, then those laws must be modified.
  With child abuse scandals unfolding one after another, and when these cases are not prevented or curbed in the current legal environment, then the time has come to make child abuse a real crime.
  Pi Yijun (www.cyol.net): It’s high time to cover child abuse in the Criminal Law. However, this new crime does not end in preventing teachers from abusing children in kindergartens, and it does not only target physical injuries either. More importantly, this crime is expected to change parents’ traditional ideas and mentality. China’s Constitution and its laws on compulsory education and protection of minors all ban child abuse, but they are not clear enough to protect children from crimes.
  Child abuse refers to more than teachers mistreating children in kindergarten; it covers all kinds of damage done to minors.
  China’s current law on the protection of minors is not fully capable of dealing with child abuse cases. Worse still, it lacks a set of effective judicial procedures that can put this law into practice. Children are weak and are dependent on the adults present in their lives. They are often not able to ask for help. The existing laws have no explicit stipulations to prevent or solve their cases.
  He Ping (Shanghai Evening Post): China’s laws relating to child abuse generally address parent-child relationships, but fail to cover abuse of children by their teachers. Punishing a teacher accused of abusing a student requires physical evidence of “intentional harm.” Without such visible damage, the lawsuit is invalid. In the Wenling case, the child was not seriously hurt, so his teacher could not be criminally charged. Instead, the police did arrest the teacher for provoking a disturbance. In this crime a suspect can face jail time of up to seven years if convicted. This example shows that child abuse must be addressed by the Criminal Law.
  Wang Yong (Procuratorial Daily): Children are defenseless and must be given special protection under the law. Abuse affects children not only physically but mentally as well. However, it’s not easy for the law to judge the damage on one’s mental health, as it is not outwardly evi- dent. It not only makes the identification of the crime difficult, but also challenges the parents as they try to defend their children’s rights.
  Liu Xianquan (Legal Daily): Is it necessary for child abuse to be covered in the Criminal Law? While it is a global issue, criminal legislation differs from one country to another.
  For example, in New Zealand there are special charges relating to child abuse, referred to as the crime of abusing minors. Those who are accountable for abusing or allowing others to abuse minors under their jurisdiction will be jailed for up to five years. In regions like Hong Kong, those who are responsible for child abuse will be jailed for a maximum of 10 years.
  Although not all countries and regions have a special crime on child abuse in their criminal codes, most of them attach great importance to the problem.
  Given the legal punishment of child abuse around the world, we find that if a country is able to effectively safeguard children’s rights and interests, they have one thing in common: They have a well-developed and mature legal system on child protection.
  In Britain, once social workers have found an abused child, they will immediately contact the police, and at the same time move the child to a safe place. In Japan, the government has set up a special consultation agency for child abuse cases. Professional workers will inspect and deal with the case, helping to work out solutions.
  Based on these examples, we can see that setting up a special crime for child abuse is not the only way to solve the problem. We need a comprehensive reporting and supervisory mechanism to effectively protect children and maximize their rights and interests.
  As for the child abuse scandals recently made public, I don’t think we need to set up a child abuse crime in the Criminal Law. Instead, I think it’s unwise to add a new crime to the Criminal Law following every scandal. We already have laws to curb child abuse. Some child abuse cases are not so serious that have to be treated as a crime; thus, it’s unnecessary to ask the suspects take criminal accountability. Criminal Law only works when all the other laws fail to address the issues at hand.
  Of course, those who abuse children should be always severely punished. If what they do is a crime, they should be punished with the charge of “intentional injury.” If it is not serious, then it’s improper to deliberately link them to “crimes.” It’s enough to punish them with administrative regulations or fines.
  The priority now is to set up an inclusive and comprehensive legal system on child protection, as well as special child protection welfare agencies. This is the most effective way to protect children’s health, physically and mentally.
其他文献
随着我国军事改革的不断深入,军校教员结构的不断优化和调整,一大批青年教育加入学校课堂教学队伍中,并且在其中发挥着十分重要的作用.大多数青年教员的学历较高、教学思维比
建筑行业的蓬勃发展给我国经济的增长带来了机遇和挑战,随着社会生活水平的提高,人们对建筑业的质量要求越来越高,为了能够给群众带来安全满意的建筑体,需要对建筑工程的各个
在“房住不炒”这一定位下,各地深入落实“一城一策”,房地产市场进一步趋稳,德荣房地产开发集团有限公司(以下简称“德荣集团”)对于政府的调控决心和调控的长期性有了清醒
期刊
期刊
【摘要】高职实践教学已经成为培养实用人才的有效教学手段,实践教学体系的建构要从教育思想、培养方案、师资培训、基地建设、课堂改革、实践教学活动开展等方面展开工作。  【关键词】高职教育;实践教学;体系构建    引言  随着经济的高速发展和科技日益进步,高等教育呈现出多元化、多层次的发展态势,以实践能力为核心的职业能力培养成为衡量高职教育质量高低的重要指标之一。在教育部《高等教育面向21世纪教学内容
促音是日语语音中的特有现象,一般出现在多音节词中。其中许多成对词在词义方面相同,以促音与非促音两种形式并存,形成了日语词汇中的一个特色。考察结果表明,促音词同非促音
在日常教学中,我经常指引学生在观察现象的时候能认识本质,在思索的过程中就会对一个问题有所认识,这样写出的文章才会有内容。也可以让学生写写自己的理想,自己的回忆。 In
生态化的作文教学,其教学核心就是立足一个“真”字,教师要引导学生从真实的实践中找素材、在描述事件中流露自己的真情实感、在选择题材时发挥自己的个性风格。 The teachi
飞行专业的学生是民航职业飞行员的候选人,民航产业技术的快速发展,就对飞行员的综合素质提出了高要求.当代的飞行专业的大学生,必须具备理论扎实、技术过硬、身心强健、责任
随着我国经济的不断发展,广播电视台事业也在不断的向前发展.为了满足人们的生活需要,广播电视节目也越来越多,越来越能够反应时代特色.在信息化不断发展的背景下,广播电视台