论文部分内容阅读
1.最近读到《汉字文化》(1995年第1期)登载的一篇题为《树立科学的现代争鸣意识》(下称《意识》)的文章,觉得该文中存在一些比较严重的问题,现提出来讨论。 2.《意识》全文中仅几个过渡性句子是作者自己的话,余皆引文。由于作者对所引观点持“同意”态度,整篇文章不能说没有观点。重要的是文章提出一个极有意义和价值的问题——树立科学的现代争鸣意识。遗憾的是文章的作者并没有就此问题进行深入的探讨,提出自己的见解。恰恰相反,文章的作者缺乏学术批评中应有的实事求是的态度,胡乱引用几句别人的话,未做任何分析便下结论,因此得出的结论与事实完全不符。《意识》一文以“树立科学的现代争鸣意识”为名,对积极开展正确的学术批评的伍铁平教授进行诽谤和攻击。这种作法有损我国语言学界(乃至整个学术界)开展正确的学术批评,不利于我国语言科学的健康发展,应该加以批评。应该说,当前我国语言学界的正确的学术批评不是太多,而是太少了。如今,刚刚有人起来开展这种批评,
1. Recently read an essay entitled “Constructing a Scientific Modern Consciousness of Consciousness” (hereinafter referred to as “Consciousness”) published in “Chinese Character Culture” (No. 1, 1995) and found that there are some serious problems in the article, Now put forward to discuss. 2. “Consciousness” only a few transitional sentences in the author’s own words, Yu Jie quotations. Due to the author’s “agree” attitude toward the points cited, the whole article can not be said without point of view. The important point is that the article proposes a question of great significance and value - to establish a scientific sense of modern contention. Unfortunately, the author of the article did not discuss this issue in depth, put forward their own views. On the contrary, the author of the article lacks the realistic attitude it should have in academic criticism. When it comes to making a random quotation of some other people, it concludes without any analysis that the conclusion is totally inconsistent with the facts. The article “Consciousness” slanders and attacks Professor Wu Tieping, who actively conducts the correct academic criticism, in the name of “establishing a scientific awareness of modern contestation.” This practice is detrimental to the correct academic criticism of the Chinese linguistic community (and even to the academic community as a whole), which is detrimental to the sound development of Chinese language science and should be criticized. It should be said that at present the correct academic criticism of our linguistic circles is not too much, but too little. Now, some people have just started to carry out such criticisms.