不表意自由与人格权保护——以赔礼道歉民事责任为中心

来源 :中国社会科学 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:sunmoon
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
言论自由与人格权保护的冲突,包括表意自由与人格权保护的冲突、不表意自由与人格权保护的冲突,二者皆属于基本权利冲突。不表意自由与人格权保护冲突应通过妥当解释消除影响、恢复名誉与赔礼道歉此两项民事责任来调适。赔礼道歉是一种在我国法律体系中广泛存在的法律责任,在比较法上获得普遍认可,作为民事责任对于打击金钱至上观念、维护市民法的伦理性具有不可或缺性。消除影响、恢复名誉与赔礼道歉作为民事责任皆符合宪法。消除影响、恢复名誉针对的是诽谤,是事实陈述问题,赔礼道歉针对的是侮辱,是意见表达问题;前者可以强制被执行人澄清事实而还原真相,后者无法强制被执行人真诚悔过并致歉,只能通过判决宣示正义。良法之治应唤醒人的良知,法律与道德应各司其职,共同保障和发展人格权。 Conflicts between freedom of expression and protection of personality rights, including the conflict between freedom of expression and protection of personality rights, and the conflict between the freedom of expression and the protection of personal rights, are both fundamental rights conflicts. The conflict between the unwarranted freedom and the protection of personality rights should be adjusted by properly explaining the two civil responsibilities of eliminating the influence, restoring the reputation and apologizing for the indemnity. Apology is a kind of legal liability widely existing in the legal system of our country. It is generally recognized in the comparative law. As a civil liability, it is indispensable as a civil liability to combat the supremacy of money and safeguard the ethics of civil law. Elimination of impact, restoration of honor and apology as civil liability are in line with the Constitution. Elimination of impact, reputation restoration is defamation, is a matter of fact statement, apologize for the insult is the expression of opinion; the former can force the enforcer to clarify the facts and restore the truth, the latter can not force the enforcer to repent and apologize in good faith Justice can only be declared through judgments. The rule of good law should awaken the conscience of the people, and law and morality should work their own ways to jointly safeguard and develop the right of personality.
其他文献
最近一年,住在重庆繁华闹市区解放碑附近某高级公寓里的赵先生对各种深夜打扰不胜其烦,他居住小区的三栋公寓楼一年里冒出来300多家“网红”民宿。针对一些居民的咨询和投诉,重
报纸
党的十八大提出,推进经济结构战略性调整,是加快转变经济发展方式的主攻方向。工业是国民经济的主导.是加快转变经济发展方式和调整优化经济结构的主战场。推进经济转型升级,工业
目的探究动态心电图在心律失常检测中的临床应用与诊断价值。方法择选2018年5月—2019年4月该院收治的心律失常患者80例为研究对象,按照计算机随机方法,均分为研究组和对照组
在严峻形势下,平禹一矿党委紧紧围绕企业生产经营管理和改革发展实际,以夯实的载体建设、创新的方式方法,找准了党建工作融入的关键点及结合点,推动了企业健康发展,开创了党建工作