以前读到许多文章,把鸳鸯蝴蝶派、礼拜六派描画的很不堪,一棍子打入十八层地下,又踏上一万只脚。对这样的说法作法,我总心存疑惑,甚至反感。一种文学流派存在了那么久,又拥有那么多的读者,总不至于一塌糊涂,一无是处得不屑一评吧?干吗非要把它与“新文学”誓不两立的对立起来呢?能不能在批判它打倒它之前,做些理性的分析,还其一个比较客观比较公正的面目。刘扬体先生说过:“在我国现 Previously read many articles, the mandarin duck and butterfly pie, the Saturday school is very unhappy, one stick into the ground floor, and set foot on 10,000. I am always puzzled and even disgusted with this way of saying things. A genre of literature has existed for so long and has so many readers that it is always not a mess, a criticism of what is right or not, what is the opposite of ”new literature“? We can not do some rational analysis before criticizing it for its overthrow, but also give us a more objective and fair view. Mr. Liu Yangti said: ”Now in our country