论文部分内容阅读
熊维章、陈尚第两同志写的“放火犯、杀人犯一律都算专政对象吗”?一文(见“人民司法”第12期)中,举出刘祖杰放火一案为例,论证放火犯、杀人犯不能一律都算专政对象。我认为这个意见值得商榷。熊、陈两同志认为刘祖杰放火一案的性质是人民内部矛盾,不是敌我矛盾的主要理由是:刘祖杰是中农成份,年轻妇女,被捕前是建团对象、青年积极分子、生产队长:犯罪的动机出于一时气愤;犯罪的目的只涉及到个人,不是敌视、破环社会主义等等。我的看法跟熊、陈两同志相反,认为杀人犯、放火犯应该一律算作专政对象,刘祖杰放火一案
In the article “People’s Justice,” No.12, written by Xiong Weizhang and Comrade Chen Shang, both comrades of “arsonists and murderers are all objects of dictatorship.” In the article, Liu Zujie cited the case of arson as an example to demonstrate that arsonists and murderers Can not always be considered a dictatorship. I think this opinion is questionable. The main reason why Liu and Zelong believed that the nature of Liu Zujie’s arson was a contradiction among the people and not a contradiction between the enemy and ourselves is that Liu Zujie is a member of the middle peasants and a young woman. Before his arrest, he was a target group, activist and captain of production: criminal Motivated by the moment of anger; the purpose of the crime involves only individuals, not hostility, breaking socialism and so on. My view with the bears, Chen comrades on the contrary, that murderers, arson should be counted as dictatorship, Liu Zujie arson case