杨武泉同志《西汉晚期至萧齐海南岛不在大陆王朝版图之外》一文的取证与论断,鄙见认为都难以成立。此处对杨文提出的质难,一一作出答复。一、《北堂书钞》卷七三引谢承《后汉书》载:交阯刺史周敞涉海遇风,船欲颠覆,别驾陈茂有异术,仗剑呵骂水神,风济得息一则,夹有“敞欲到朱崖儋耳”一句,杨文据以作为东汉顺帝时海南岛上有交阯刺史辖境之证;并认为这条记载“正契合合 Comrade Yang Wuquan’s ”evidence from the later Western Han Dynasty to the late Qing Dynasty in Qi’s South Island not in the territory of the mainland dynasty“ won the pretext and assertion that it is difficult to establish his opinion. Yang Wen raised here the quality of the problem, one by one reply. First, the ”North Hall book notes“ volume seven three cited Xiezheng ”Han“ contains: provincial governor Zhou Zong involved sea encounters the wind, the ship wants to subvert, do not drive Chen Mao have different skills, sword scolding water god, wind economy An interest rate, with ”open to Zhu Cliff ear " a sentence, Yang Wen according to the Eastern Han Dynasty Emperor Shun when there is an address in the jurisdiction of the governor of Hainan Province; and that this record Together