科学技术是不是生产力？本文在充分理解该判断提出的最初始的善意动机的基础上，通过对马克思和恩格斯在生产力理论的回顾及其对庸俗生产力理论的批判，明确指出这一判断的理论失误和逻辑混乱之处。同时分析了该判断产生的直接原因──板块思维，以及这种思维方式的社会广延性。 Science and technology is not productivity? Based on a full understanding of the initial motives of goodwill proposed by this judgment, this article clearly points out the theoretical mistakes and logical chaos of this judgment through the review of Marx’s and Engels’ theory of productive forces and their critique of vulgar productivity theory. At the same time, it analyzes the direct reasons for the judgment ─ ─ plate thinking, as well as the social extension of this way of thinking.