Semioethics and Literary Writing:Between Peirce and Bakhtin

来源 :Language and Semiotic Studies | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:jialufeng
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
In the early phase of its development, semiotics was understood as “semeiotics” and studied symptoms. Today we propose to recover this ancient dimension of semiotics focussed on health, care and the quality of life, and reorganise it in semioethical terms. In fact, as interference increases in communication between the historico-social sphere and the biological, between culture and nature, between the semiosphere and the biosphere, the need for a “semioethical turn” in the study of signs with an understanding of the relation of signs to values has become ever more urgent.Literary writing is particularly interesting from this perspective thanks to its extraordinary capacity to stage values that animate life to the best in terms of the properly human. These values are characterized by high degrees of opening to the other, by responsiveness/answerability toward the other, by a propensity for listening to the other, for giving time to the other.Construed on relations of distancing and at once of affinity among signs, metaphor—or more broadly imagery, fi gurative language—is emblematic of literary writing, though not limited to it. As amply demonstrated by Victoria Welby, far from serving as a mere decorative supplement, the fi gurative dimension of expression is structural to signifying processes, to the acquisition itself of knowledge and understanding. Welby’s work may be read as prefi guring recent trends in language studies as represented by cognitive linguistics today.Mikhail Bakhtin has also made an important contribution in this sense. He has developed the study of signs in terms of moral philosophy and, in fact, his approach to semiotics is easily oriented in the sense of semioethics. In such a framework he evidences the close relationship between sign studies and literary writing. For a full understanding of the sense of Bakhtin’s approach to studies on verbal language, it is important to highlight his insistence on the inexorable interconnection—which he describes as direct and dialectical—between literary language and life. Bakhtin deals with questions of literary writing from the perspective of literature itself. His excursions outside the fi eld of literature do not imply recourse to an external viewpointwith claims to offering a description that is totalizing and systemic. On the contrary, Bakhtin remains inside literature and never leaves it; literature is his observation post, the perspective from which he conducts his critique, which is anti-systemic and detotalizing. Bakhtin reveals the internal threads that connect literature to the extra-literary, thematizing the condition of structural intertextuality in the connection between literary texts and extra-literary texts. In Bakhtin’s view, the literary text subsists and develops in its specifi city as a literary text thanks to its implication with the external universe. Such implication is also understood in an ethical sense.Charles Peirce’s semiotics as well has a focus on the relation between cognition, the interpersonal relation, communication and moral value. He evidences the development of signifying pathways(the open-ended chain of interpretants) which he describes as potentially infi nite, the role of the imagination and musement in abductive inferential processes, of similarity(in particular the agapastic) in metaphor, and of metaphor in abduction with its capacity for invention and innovation. All this makes Peirce’s Collected Papers another precious source for refl ection, together with Bakhtin’s texts, on the relation between semioethics and literary writing. In the early phase of its development, semiotics was understood as “semeiotics ” and studied symptoms. Today we propose to recover this ancient dimension of semiotics focussed on health, care and the quality of life, and reorganise it in semioethical terms. In fact, as interference increases in communication between the historico-social sphere and the biological, between culture and nature, between the semiosphere and the biosphere, the need for a “semioethical turn ” in the study of signs with an understanding of the relation of signs to values ​​has become ever more urgent.Literary writing is substantially interesting from this perspective thanks to its extraordinary capacity to stage values ​​that animate life to the best in terms of the proper human. These values ​​are characterized by high degrees of opening to the other, by responsiveness / answerability toward the other, by a propensity for listening to the other, for giving time to the other. Construed on relations of distancing and at once of affinity among signs, metaphor-or more broadly imagery, fi gurative language-is emblematic of literary writing, though not limited to it. As amply demonstrated by Victoria Welby, far from serving as a mere decorative supplement, the fi gurative dimension of expression is structural to signifying processes, to the acquisition itself of knowledge and understanding. Welby’s work may be read as prefi guring recent trends in language studies as represented by cognitive linguistics today. Mikhail Bakhtin has also made an important contribution in this sense. He has developed the study of signs in terms of moral philosophy and, in fact, his approach to semiotics is easily oriented in the sense of semioethics. In such a framework he evidences the close relationship between sign studies and literary writing. For a full understanding of the sense of Bakhtin’s approach to studies on verbal language, it is important to highlight his insistence on the inexorable interconnection-whic h he describes as direct and dialectical-between literary language and life. Bakhtin deals with questions of literary writing from the perspective of literature itself. His excursions outside the fi eld of literature do not imply recourse to an external viewpointwith claims to offering a description that is totalizing On the contrary, Bakhtin remains inside literature and never leaves it; literature is his observation post, the perspective from which he conducts his critique, which is anti-systemic and detotalizing. Bakhtin reveals the internal threads that connect literature to the extra -literary, thematizing the condition of structural intertextuality in the connection between literary texts and extra-literary texts. In Bakhtin’s view, the literary text subsists and develops in its specifi city as a literary text thanks to its implication with the external universe. Such implication is also understood in an ethical sense. Charles Peirce’s semiotics as well has a focus on the relation between cognition, the interpersonal relation, communication and moral value. He evidences the development of signifying pathways (the open-ended chain of interpretants) which he describes as potentially infi nite, the role of the imagination and musement in abductive inferential processes, of similarity (in particular the agapastic) in metaphor, and of metaphor in abduction with its capacity for invention and innovation. All this makes Peirce’s Collected Papers another precious source for reflction, together with Bakhtin’s texts, on the relation between semioethics and literary writing.
其他文献
本文报道了[KAs_4W_(40)O_(140)(M·H_2O_2]~(n-)杂多阴离子中配位水的取代反应.在水溶液中,许多配体,如[Fe(CN)_6]~(4-)、[Fe(CN)_6]~(3-),SO_3~(2-)等都能取代配位水形成具
从经济体制改革的实践看中国经济体制转轨的特色□陈达恒中国的经济体制改革,已经走过了18年多的光辉历程,取得了举世瞩目的成效,积累了丰富的经验,也付出了一定的代价。回顾中国经
从2016年11月初开始,我的工作就进入到122“全国交通安全日”倒计时的模式,而这一天终于来到了。2016年12月2日晚上6点,长时间的忙碌戛然而止。我和同为交警的老公开车去县城
上世纪50年代初,我国广大农村掀起了农业合作化的高潮,各地也在实践中积累了不少经验。其中,辽宁省彰武县大德乡根据合作化发展过程中出现的会计人员短缺、会计人员素质不高
实验教学是初中科学教学的重要组成部分,对于培养学生的科学认知、思维和体验具有重要价值,如何打造有效的实验课堂是初中科学教师亟须解决的问题。本文结合教学实践,着重分
在市场经济条件下,我国传统的国库分散支付制度的弊端日益凸显,无法适应现代公共财政的需要。因此,实行国库集中支付制度就产生了十分积极的作用和极为重要的现实意义。但毕
随着社会经济的不断发展和城市化进程的不断加快,城市的人口数量获得了迅猛的增长,交通问题已经成为大城市当前所面临的重要问题.与此同时,城市道路交通噪声日益突出,严重影
珠三角地区是我国内河航运较为发达的地区,本文通过分析珠三角地区内河航运企业发展面临的问题,引入价值链管理理念,分别就提升珠三角内河航运企业竞争力的内部价值链管理和
期刊
摘要:五年制高职院校的常规教学包括公共基础课教学、专业理论课教学和专业实训课教学,这三个方面的教学在学生职业精神培养方面都发挥着基础性作用,但是又在不同程度上存在“两张皮”现象,对学生职业能力提升及职业精神培养具有一定的消极影响。因此,本文阐述了如何在常规教学环节中培养高职生的职业精神。  关键词:五年制高职院校 常规教学 职业精神  一、公共基础课教学中的职业精神培养  五年制高职院校在很大程度