《测井技术》1983年第4期刊登的“康普顿效应能量衰减—距离关系式的探讨”(以下简称“探讨”),阅后有些观点愿与作者商榷。1.“探讨”的主要论点是:密度测井的脊肋图在一定程度上的非直线和非等刻度性质是由于能量衰减所致。但是没有提出令人信服的解释。当仪器测得的结果存在非线性关系时,应全面地从两方面分析:一方面分析事物本身是否存在非线性关系,另一方面分析测量仪器是否有非线 “Well Logging Technology”, Issue 4, 1983, “Compton Effect Energy Attenuation - Discussion on Distance Relationship” (hereinafter referred to as “Discussion”). Some views after reading this article are willing to be discussed with the author. 1. The main argument of “exploration” is that the non-linear and non-isoalistic nature of the ridge graph of density logs is due to the energy decay. However, no convincing explanation was given. When the instrument measured the results of non-linear relationship, it should be comprehensively analyzed from two aspects: on the one hand, the analysis of things whether there is a non-linear relationship, on the other hand analysis of the measuring instrument is non-linear