论文部分内容阅读
【裁判要旨】行使票据利益返还请求权并不以存在基础关系为必要条件,如果票据债务人欲以持票人不履行约定义务作为抗辩理由,则其须证明与持票人之间有直接的基础关系。■案号一审:(2012)深龙法民二初字第200号二审:(2012)深中法涉外终字第163号【案情】广东省深圳市龙岗区龙东龙达家私厂(以下简称龙达厂)系香港龙达家私装饰公司(以下简称龙达公司)在深圳市龙岗区开办的三来一补企业。2009年12月30日,龙达厂开具金额为人民币103560元的支票1张,支票上注明的收款
The purpose of the referee The exercise of the right to claim the return of the instrument is not based on the existence of a fundamental relationship as a necessary condition. If a debtor wants to defend the bearer’s obligations as a defense, the debtor must prove that it has a direct and fundamental relationship with the bearer . ■ Case No. First instance: (2012) Shen Long Fa Min Er Chu Zi No. 200 Second Trial: (2012) Shen Zhong Fa Foreign Affairs Final No. 163 【Case】 Longdong Longda Furniture Factory, Longgang District, Shenzhen Referred to as Longda plant) Department of Hong Kong Longda furniture decoration company (hereinafter referred to Ronda Company) in Longgang District, Shenzhen opened three to make up a business. On December 30, 2009, Longda Plant issued a check amounting to RMB 105,560 and a check on the receipt