清史学界对皇八子允禩、皇九子允禟的死因多有歧说,一种意见认为允禩、允搪是被其四兄雍正帝指使心腹杀害的,即非正常死亡;另种意见则认为允禩、允搪是在狱中病故的,应属于正常死亡。坚执前说的专家学者颇多,笔者也持此观点。孟森在《海宁陈家》一文中写道:“若以史实衡之,则弘 In the history of the Qing Dynasty, there were many differences between the scholars of the royal court and those of the imperial clan of Yun-k’ai, and that of the imperial clan of the imperial clan in the imperial clan of Yun-k’ai. In one opinion, Yun-bian and Yun-bian were instructed by their four brothers, Emperor Yongzheng, to kill with disobedience, That allow 禩, allow enamel is dead in prison, should belong to normal death. Firmly said before the experts and scholars quite a lot, I also hold this view. Meng Sen in the “Haining Chen family,” a article wrote: "If the historical balance, then Hong