《价值与认知:档案存毁之间的博弈》再次提出了弱化档案鉴定的观点。文章针对部分作者的文章做了批评,引用了诸多案例,来证明自己的观点。然而其论述有自相矛盾之处,其批评也有断章取义之嫌,案例引用亦有不当之处。文章反映了作者对现实中的档案工作严重缺乏了解。 “Value and cognition: the game between file storage and destruction” once again put forward the view of weakening file identification. The article criticizes some authors’ articles and cites many cases to prove their point of view. However, there are contradictions in its discourse, and its criticism is also suspected of being out of context. The citation of cases is also inappropriate. The article reflects the author’s serious lack of understanding of the reality of the file work.