对《质疑三则》之商榷重庆／水绍韩《语文教学通讯》１９９７年第３期刊载的张敏英《质疑三则》一文（以下称为张文）的三点见解，均有失误，值得进一步商榷。一、《宋定伯捉鬼》一文有：“道遇水，定伯令鬼先渡，听之，了然无声音。定伯自渡，漕作声。”课本对其中“漕?.. The three questions of Zhang Minying’s “Questioning Three” (hereafter referred to as Zhang Wen) published in the 3rd issue of the 1997 issue of Chongqing/Water Shaohan’s “Language Teaching Newsletter” on the “Questioning Three” were all mistakes. Further discussion. First, “Song Dingbo’s Buffy” article reads: “The Taoist encounters the water, and it is determined that the ghosts will cross first, and they will hear it. There will be no sound. Dingbo Zidu will be the sound.”