Catching Meaning while Forgetting Image,an Illustration Based on Evolution in Arts and Primitive Cla

被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:lee419444083
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
One of Alfred C. Haddon’s most no-table achievements must be his fieldwork on the Torres Strait Islands. Based on fieldwork material, he illustrated the life history of designs in his book Evolution in Arts. In this book he mentioned that the study of art should be separated from the hu-man mind and personal preference. He suggested three basic rules: first,even the history of art fol-lows the rule of evolution,all the symbols,no mat-ter simple or complex,have an original source. Sec-ond,in order to explain why different tribes or cul-tures have the same symbols,anthropologists should make their conclusions based upon detailed materi-als and scientific methods. Third, bcause we can find the origin of art and the meaning of symbols by analyzing present symbols,simpler civilizations and cultures might be a good start. From these three rules,it is quite clear that Haddon wanted to sum-marize the life history of designs from fieldwork material. However,the main idea of this article is to uncover the hidden structure of this history, apart from evolutionism. In this way, not only is the change of the symbol’s meaning mentioned,but E-mile Durkheim’s and Marcel Mauss’ famous work Primitive Classification will also be compared in the following paragraphs. Alfred C. Haddon found that the “Line” and the “Curve” were the most basic designs in Papua New Guinea. He found that the use of different de-signs have a connection with geographical location. But how were they connected? And,how did local residents understand these designs? Haddon noted that even in these primitive cultures, the meaning of the symbols were not primitive. Those lines and curves were not as simple as we thought. Haddon believed that they all derived from the portrayal of local animals and plants. For instance,the polygo-nal line came from the description of the crocodile, and curves got their image from birds. In other words, before the images of specific animals or plants had been simplified, the line or curve did not have any decorative meaning. However, after that process, tribes did not choose their main de-signs based on the aesthetic preference,but on the meaning of that design. It was in this way the de-signs were entrusted with a life. And,the life histo-ry of designs referred to,in one specific culture,the process from an objective fact to the aesthetic con-cept,that is,from the collective memory to individ-ual preference. As Alfred C. Haddon tried to separate the study of art from individual preference, Emile Durkheim also held the idea that instead of it being a personal idea,the classification of ability also had its foundation in society. The fact is that before Primitive Classification, people had no idea where did they got the ability of classify. In Durkheim and Mauss’ opinion,this ability had a close connection with the process through which humans evolved a logical cognition to this society. By analyzing primi-tive classification in Australia and Papua New Guinea,they wanted to know how those people rec-ognized this world. In this way,the classification of thinking was an important prehistory history. Durkheim and Mauss mentioned two types of primitive classification. One of them was found mainly in Australia. For the first time, people in Australia classified human and nature features into different categories. This was based on their kinship system. However, after the introduction of affinity, the system became more complex,and the concept of hierarchy emerged. The other type was based on phratry and clan. This kind of system was more complete,and the entire universe was classified in-to each clan and their branches. Obviously more categories emerged,and what should be noticed is that,unlike the first kind,in this stage the rules of classification began to be forgotten. Although peo-ple still mentioned why something should be put into a specific category, the hierarchical relation-ships between different categories were not as clear as before. Did this system work in all the cultures? Durkheim and Mauss soon raised this question,and in Papua New Guinea, this kind of classification system can be found in local social institutions. In fact,local social institutions, as soon as they exis-ted,would also influence the classification system. As we have already mentioned, the hierarchy be-tween different categories was not clear any more, nor were the primitive structure and the classifica-tion rules. However although the system still exis-ted,the structure now turned to the many individu-al groups. The most complex and extreme type of classification was found among Zuni People. They used the principle of geography to replace the prin-ciple of kinship. In the former,the concept of totem played an important role in the classification. How-ever,the relationship was no longer connected with an awareness of nature, but with a mechanistic structure. In this way,we can find that at first,fea-tures were classified based on clan and totem,and the entire universe was classified in this way. This also led to the change of the individual mode of thinking. When the hierarchy of clan began to dis-appear, the principles of classification also changed. In Durkheim and Mauss’ ideas,no matter whether the principle changed or not,they all came from the society instead of from any other con-cepts. After contrasting these two books, we now would like to summarize the relationship between primitive classification and the life history of de-sign. We start with the life history of design. Had-don believed that all designs and arts got their im-age from utilitarian objects or existing creatures. As we mentioned before, designs were entrusted with life when they have meaning. The meaning may have relationship with nature,or maybe it also has a relationship with primitive religion. However,both the human mind and the religion became more complex. The meaning of designs was no longer clear,and this led to the last stage of a design, namely as a simple decoration. Nowadays, most of the designs ( in our culture ) are in the last stage;artists and individuals have forgotten the original meaning of the designs. However,there was no spe-cific meaning to take the place of the old one. Peo-ple use different designs as they like. We have to realize that both the analysis of designs and the research of classification systems have the same process. At the beginning, designs and the classification system were regarded as both abstract and from a personal aspect. And,no regu-lar laws could be found. We have already forgotten the original way to understand this world,just as we have forgotten the original meanings of symbols and designs. Secondly, as we can find from Haddon’s fieldwork material,he believed that all the designs can be traced back to an animal or a plant. Just like most primitive classification was based on clan and kinship relations,only after the rules of classi-fication and hierarchy became unclear, did the principles of classification turn from kinship to ge-ography. And now we can find a similar structure behind the life history of designs and the principles of classification. Although Alfred C. Haddon used“evolution” in the title of his book,it is not hard to discover that the history of life is not a simple evo-lutionary process,but is a process that involved not only evolution but also regression. The meaning of designs once became clear, and finally turned to being unclear. Only in the last stage did personal preference or individualism begin to play an impor-tant role. Both society and the collective memory lead to a relative stable way to understand the world and designs. However, they cannot be fixed since the design itself also changes. Nowadays,people choose to use different meanings to express personal inter-ests and uniqueness. However,this is just a special example of the structure. Although it is special, it still follows structure. Primitive classification was not totally different from the classification system used for science. They both derived from the way people understand the world in which they lived. Of course,the primitive classification system had more connection with collective emotion,while the scien-tific classification system used individual reflection to replace emotion. But, those we have experi-enced,no matter we still remember or not,still ex-isted in our whole classification system,perhaps in the form of myth or religion, and in our mode of thinking. To summarize,this article does not want mere-ly to illustrate the similar process between the life history of design and primitive classification,but it wants to analyze how early anthropological studies focused on “how did human civilization emerge”. In other words,the article wants to find the social history behind the life history of designs. This arti-cle also does not want to prove that a general de-velopment process exists, but it wants to uncover the process which goes from collective memory to individualism. Alfred C. Haddon, Emile Durkheim and Marcel Mauss, all their studies show that in primitive tribes,designs did not appear from noth-ing;they came from sensory experience about na-ture. However,when new concepts and culture were inserted into the designs,people began to forget the simple association. Finally, as the designs became more abstract, so did the mode of thinking of hu-mans. The fact is,this already forgotten process still exists in and acts upon our minds.
其他文献
奖品长春市凹凸岛体育用品有限公司风雨者户外套装简介风雨者(Rainingman clothing)专业套装是凹凸岛中高档户外套装代表作品之一。本款服装采用双层外复合结构设计,防雨和透
来自麦肯锡咨询公司的一份新报告显示,当集装箱船只抵达港口,班轮公司联盟在海上的规模优势便走到尽头.对联盟来说,扩大其陆运合作以提高效率和盈利能力,是其未来业务发展的
期刊
这两个月参加了好几个与石油和海外投资有关的论坛,明显感觉到一种“走出去”的冲动:走出去,我们需要资源;走出去,我们有钱;走出去,到处都是机会;走出去,我们已经积蓄了足够
期刊
随着我国企业不断的“走出去”,跨境并购成为资产评估服务的热点领域。本文以国内上市公司收购境外互联网广告供应端平台公司为例,对上市公司跨境并购采用收益法进行评估的过程
期刊
北京奥运会已于2008年8月23日胜利闭幕.笔者所在公司在天津市第一中心医院(国家奥组委指定医院)、天津市奥体中心、天津博物馆等项目的全体秩序维护人员服从天津奥运安保领导
第二届中国国际进口博览会(CIIE)于2019年11月5日在上海隆重开幕。全球知名的营养品公司康宝莱携旗下20多类50多种海外畅销产品再度亮相进博会,传递营养+运动的健康生活方式。  在进博会期间,康宝莱中国区总裁郭木先生接受媒体采访,分享了康宝莱近期在华的投资计划、举措以及未来在中国市场的发展战略,进一步表明了康宝莱坚定抓住机遇,深耕中国市场决心和信心。  问:您对进博会有怎样的期待?期望从进博
期刊
为了取得更好的发展,延长油田突出转变发展方式主线,努力向科技增油转变、向精细管理转变、向自主创新转变。 In order to achieve better development, the Group will ext
期刊
巍峨延绵的武陵山脉,横亘在鄂湘渝三省(市)之交。在大山腹地,以“有凤来仪”的美丽传说而得名的湖北来凤县旧司镇库区,有一对美名传扬的“夫妻村医”,广受当地村民的爱戴。他们就
一年一度的中央企业、地方国资委负责人会议于1月15日在北京召开.国务院国资委在总结工作、分析形势的基础上,研究部署了2018年的重点任务.rn国务院国资委主任肖亚庆在会议上
期刊