本刊2005年第2期刊登了任定华、杨忠民先生批评阙道隆先生《编辑学理论纲要》的文章,题目为《编辑学理论的构建应具有科学的、严密的知识体系》,对编辑学理论应包括哪些内容、编辑与编辑学概念的界定、编辑学的学科性质、编辑与文化的关系、编辑学研究中的哲学思考等五个方面的问题提出了自己的见解。作为回应,阙先生撰写了《需要建立什么样的编辑学》一文,进一步阐述了他对编辑学的学科建设的一些想法。希望通过这样的探讨,能够深化我们对编辑学的一些重要问题的认识。 In 2005 the second issue of 2005 published Ren Dinghua, Mr. Yang Zhongmin criticized Que Doong Long “editorial board theory” article titled “Editing theory should be structured with a scientific and strict knowledge system”, editorial theory should Including what content, the definition of editorial and editing concepts, the nature of editorial disciplines, the relationship between editors and cultures, philosophical thinking in editorial studies and put forward their own views. In response, Mr. Que wrote the article, “What kind of editing science needs to be established,” and further elaborates some of his ideas on subject building in editing science. Hopefully, through this kind of discussion, we can deepen our understanding of some important issues in editing science.