论文部分内容阅读
法律不是纯粹的法律推理,正如美国著名的霍姆斯大法官所言,法律的本质不是逻辑,而是经验。纯粹的法律推理绝不是我们理想的司法状态。我们还要考虑许多法律条文之外的东西。案情:2003年8月9日,董某与某开发公司签订合同购买一套商品房供其全家居住。签约时开发公司的人员多次说这里的房子24小时供热水、管道煤气、自来水到户,手续齐全。11月10日看房时,董某也看到了煤气表、热水表等设施,再加上开发公司是区政府的下属公司,董某就下决心购买这房子。等到
Law is not purely legal reasoning. Just as Justice James Holmes in the United States said, the essence of law is not logic, but experience. Pure legal reasoning is by no means our ideal judicial status. We also have to consider many things beyond the law. Case: August 9, 2003, Dong and a development company signed a contract to buy a commercial housing for the whole family to live. When signing the contract, the personnel of the development company repeatedly said that the house here has 24 hours of hot water, pipeline gas and tap water, and the procedures are complete. November 10 showings, Dongmou also saw gas meters, hot water meters and other facilities, coupled with the development company is a subsidiary of the district government, Dongmou determined to buy the house. wait until