论文部分内容阅读
【目的】科技期刊中的述评类综述凝聚了某一学科的研究进展、最新研究成果、潜在问题和未来发展趋势,文献价值举足轻重、学术地位不可代替,作者和办刊者需要注重述评类综述的学术质量。【方法】从选题、参考文献等方面,总结我国期刊述评类综述的学术质量存在的诸多问题。【结果】述评类综述对同行的科研工作具有很高的参考价值,也为读者提高写作水平提供借鉴。但是我国一些述评类综述的选题和内容质量参差不齐,例如选题陈旧,选题过大、内容空洞,选题与前人雷同等;在参考文献的筛查、组织管理和评论等方面,存在文献堆积,时效性和代表性差等问题。【结论】人们已经迈入碎片化阅读的时代,综述的信息含量丰富、可读性强,作者和办刊者应当从选题和参考文献质量等方面综合评价述评类综述的学术质量。
【Aim】 The review of science journals summarizes the research progress, the latest research results, potential problems and future trends of a subject. The value of the literature plays a decisive role, and academic status can not be replaced. Authors and runners need to pay attention to the review of the review. Academic quality. [Methods] From the topics, references and other aspects, summed up our review of journals summarize the academic quality of many problems. [Results] The review of review class has a high reference value for peer research work, and also provides reference for readers to improve their writing skills. However, the quality of the topics and contents of some review categories in our country are uneven. For example, the topics are outdated, the topics are too large, the content is empty, the topics are the same as the predecessors; in the screening, organization and review of the references , There is literature accumulation, timeliness and poor representation and other issues. 【Conclusion】 People have entered the era of fragmented reading. The content of the review is informative and readable. The authors and runners should comprehensively evaluate the academic quality of the review by reviewing the quality of selected topics and references.