《中学语文教学》2011年第2期刊有刘宏业老师的《敌人的炮弹为什么总是炸不到老妇人——以<蜡烛>为例谈文学作品中实用价值和审美价值的关系》一文,在文中,刘老师对“敌人的炮弹为什么总是炸不到老妇人”这一问题进行了分析,批驳了两种常见的观点,阐释了文本的主旨,并从价值的角度阐述了自己的看法。对此,笔者均有不同的观点,下面逐一加以辨析。 “High School Chinese Teaching” 2011 the second issue of Liu Hongye teacher “why the enemy’s shells always can not reach the old woman - with” candle as an example of literary works of practical value and aesthetic value of the relationship "in the article, in the In the article, Teacher Liu analyzed the issue of why the enemy shells never reach the old woman, criticized two common views, explained the main thrust of the text, and explained himself from a value point of view the opinion of. In this regard, I have different views, the following one by one to be analyzed.