Comparative clinical study of ultrasound-guided A1 pulley release vs open surgical intervention in t

来源 :World Journal of Orthopedics | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:zhuhao0000
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
AIM To investigate the effectiveness of ultrasound-guided release of the first annular pulley and compare results with the conventional open operative technique.METHODS In this prospective randomized, single-center, clinical study, 32 patients with trigger finger or trigger thumb, grade Ⅱ-Ⅳ according to Green classification system, were recruited. Two groups were formed; Group A(16 patients) was treated with an ultrasound-guided percutaneous release of the affected A1 pulley under local anesthesia. Group B(16 patients) underwent an open surgical release of the A1 pul ey, through a 10-15 mm incision. Patients were assessed pre- and postoperatively(follow-up:2,4 and 12 wk) by physicians blinded to the procedures. Treatment of triggering(primary variable of interest) was expressed as the “success rate” per digit. The time for taking postoperative pain killers, range of motion recovery, QuickD ASH test scores(Greek version), return to normal activities(including work), complications and cosmetic results were assessed.RESULTS The success rate in group A was 93.75%(15/16) and in group B 100%(16/16). Mean times in group A patients were 3.5 d for taking pain killers, 4.1 d for returning to normal activities, and 7.2 and 3.9 d for complete extension and flexion recovery, respectively. Mean Quick DASH scores in group A were 45.5 preoperatively and, 7.5, 0.5 and 0 after 2, 4, and 12 wk postoperatively. Mean times in group B patients were 2.9 d for taking pain killers, 17.8 d for returning to normal activities, and 5.6 and 3 d for complete extension and flexion recovery. Mean QuickD ASH scores in group B were 43.2 preoperatively and, 8.2, 1.3 and 0 after 2, 4, and 12 wk postoperatively. The cosmetic results found excellent or good in 87.5%(14/16) of group A patients, while in 56.25%(9/16) of group B patients were evaluated as fair or poor.CONCLUSION Treatment of the trigger finger using ultrasonography resulted in fewer absence of work days, and better cosmetic results, in comparison with the open surgery technique. It is a promising method that represents excellent results without major complications, so that it could be possibly be established as a first-line treatment in the trigger finger’s disease. AIM To investigate the effectiveness of ultrasound-guided release of the first annular pulley and compare results with the conventional open operative technique. METHODS In this prospective randomized, single-center, clinical study, 32 patients with trigger finger or trigger thumb, grade II- Group A (16 patients) was treated with an ultrasound-guided percutaneous release of the affected A1 pulley under local anesthesia. Group B (16 patients) underwent an open surgical release of the A1 pul ey, through a 10-15 mm incision. Patients were assessed pre- and postoperatively (follow-up: 2,4 and 12 wk) by physicians blinded to the procedures. Treatment of triggering (primary variable of interest) was expressed as the “success rate” per digit. The time for taking postoperative pain killers, range of motion recovery, QuickD ASH test scores (Greek version), return to normal activities (including work), complications Results of the success rate in group A were 93.75% (15/16) and in group B 100% (16/16). Mean times in group A patients were 3.5 days for taking pain killers, 4.1 days for Mean to in normal group, 7.2 and 3.9 d for complete extension and flexion recovery, respectively. Mean Quick DASH scores in group A were 45.5 preoperatively and, 7.5, 0.5 and 0 after 2, 4, and 12 wk postoperatively. B patients were 2.9 d for taking pain killers, 17.8 d for returning to normal activities, and 5.6 and 3 d for complete extension and flexion recovery. Mean QuickD ASH scores in group B were 43.2 preoperatively and, 8.2, 1.3 and 0 after 2, 4, and 12 wk postoperatively. The cosmetic results found excellent or good in 87.5% (14/16) of group A patients, while in 56.25% (9/16) of group B patients were evaluated as fair or poor. CONCLUSION Treatment of the trigger finger using ultrasonography resulted in fewer absence of work days, and better cosmetic results, i n comparison with the open surgery technique. It is a promising method that represents excellent results without major complications, so that it could be be established as a first-line treatment in the trigger finger’s disease.
其他文献
梦城发生了一件奇怪的事。一个人在街上行走,突然“嘭”的一声爆炸,如惊雷,接着冒起一股烟,那人瞬间便消失了,现场干干净净,连一点血迹都没有。最近国外发生了几起恐怖事件,
一位外交官的4个女儿艾伦、雷妮、谢莉和特莱莎都是音乐家,每个人演奏一种不同的乐器(这4种乐器分别是单簧管、笛子、钢琴和小提琴),每个人都讲一种不同的语言(这4种语言分别
丹尼尔·布尔伦(Daniel Buren)关于“建筑与反建筑的转化”的展览在木丹艺术馆大礼堂举办。木丹艺术馆和蓬皮杜·梅斯中心联合邀请各位艺术家在馆内空间的连接处进行装置创作
一、激发学生创新思维的愿望要培养学生的创新思维能力,首先应让学生感到作文中“创新”并不十分难。在我们小学阶段的近百篇作文当中,有好多命题作文可以写成同一文题而材料
民和镇派出所辖区为江西省进贤县城所在地。近年来,该所以实现人民满意为目标,密切联系群众,实行打防并举,辖区稳定,人民安居乐业。该所先后获得省公安系统“国内安全保卫工
雍容华贵的红牡丹展露出她倾国倾城般醉人的微笑,国色天香的牡丹花不知惹乱了多少行人的步伐。可是古往今来,多少文人墨客却更喜欢描写那默默无闻的小草。白居易的《赋得古原
一个带黑社会性质的武装犯罪团伙,自称“黑色武功队”,他们行踪诡秘,帮规严酷,持枪抢劫,聚众斗殴,肆意杀戮。“打黑除恶”的狂飚横扫之时。彭山警方布下罗网,全力出击,一举摧
春来家的屋后有一片桃林。四年前爷爷亲手栽下的,不多不少,整整四十棵。村子里也有人家种桃,但都是门前屋后点缀几棵,不成气候,统统加起来也不及春来家的一半。 There is a
老兄,还在跟傻乎乎、慢吞吞的计算机较劲吗?年底了,你是否已经打算给这个笨家伙升级了?先别忙,捂好你的钱包,不要让你的血汗钱便宜了哪些过时、缺乏人性化的家伙。CHIP将告诉
哈哈,愚人节又到了,小朋友们一定已经按捺不住心里那只小小的爱捉弄人的小魔兽了吧。你们都想出了哪些鬼点子呢?兵法上有三十六计, Haha, April Fool’s Day has come again