论文部分内容阅读
法律原则的研究主要以法律原则的元理论、法律原则和法律规则的界分理论以及法律原则的适用理论为进路。针对法律原则的不同进路,国内的学者均以德沃金的原则理论为起点展开了不同的解读。无论是法律原则的适用还是法律原则与法律规则的界限问题,始终不能脱离的是法律原则的元理论中的规范性理论。借由哈特与德沃金在“原则理论”和“规则理论”中的根本分歧点来对德沃金的法律原则理论进行不同的解读,从而在阐明法律原则与法律规则的内在关系基础上清晰化两者之间的界分理论和适用理论。
The research of legal principles mainly takes the meta-theory of legal principles, the demarcation theory of legal principles and legal rules as well as the applicable theory of legal principles. Different approaches to the principle of law, domestic scholars have carried out different interpretations based on the principles of Dworkin’s principle. Whether it is the application of the principle of law or the boundary between the principle of law and the rule of law, it can not be divorced from the normative theory in the meta-theory of legal principle. By interpreting Dworkin’s theory of legal principle from Hart Hart and Dworkin’s fundamental disagreement in Principles of Principles and Theory of Rules, On the basis of internal relations, it clarifies the boundary theory and applicable theory between the two.