传统声乐教育认为变声期是声乐训练的禁区,变声期严禁进行声乐训练,否则可能对少年儿童的声带造成伤害,影响到少儿变声期结束后的声乐学习。19世纪中期的声乐教师、间接喉境发明者加西亚就认为应禁声,当代美国歌喉问题权威布罗德尼兹认为:男18—19岁、女16—17岁之前不宜多练声。 Traditional vocal music education considers vocalization as a forbidden area for vocal music training and vocal training is strictly forbidden in vocalization, otherwise children’s vocal cords may be harmed and vocal music learning after children’s vocalization period may be affected. The mid-19th century vocal music teacher, indirect throat inventor Garcia that should be banned, the contemporary American voice of the judge Breod Nizi think: male 18-19 years old, 16-17 years old women should not practice more sound.