S·查鲁希拉在美刊《反思马克思主义》第19卷第1期(2007年1月)上发表了题为《过渡、目的论与分类法》的文章。文章认为,查克拉巴蒂和卡伦伯格合著的《印度的转型与发展》(2003)一书对马克思主义者围绕转型与发展的争论进行了全面的批判性的分析。他们根据后结构主义和后殖民批 S Char Luchira published an article entitled “Transition, Skopos Theory and Taxonomy” at the 19th issue of the American Journal of Reflections on Marxism, January 2007 (January 2007). The article argues that the book “Transformation and Development in India” (2003), by Chakrabatti and Kahlenberg, provides a comprehensive and critical analysis of the Marxist arguments surrounding transformation and development. They are based on post-structuralism and post-colonialism