“保护学生言说欲的最大敌人就是‘考试’”;“写作教学从一开始培养的就是独特性,所追求的就是陌生化”;“写作素养不是教出来、训练出来的,而是自我涵养、修炼出来的”;“离开了写作,阅读就是浪费生命。”这些观点有一个共同特征,就是对立。让“保护学生言说欲”与“考试”对立,让写作的独特性与写作的普遍规律对立,让“自我涵养、修炼”与“教”、“训练”对立,让“写作”与“阅读”对立。如若把他们放到矫枉先过正的特殊角度,仔细琢磨的话还是有其一定价值的。但 “The greatest enemy to protect students’ desire to speak is the examination ” “Writing teaching is unique from the very beginning, the pursuit is unfamiliar ” “Writing literacy is not taught, training out, But self-cultivation, training out ”;“ left writing, reading is a waste of life. ”These views have a common feature is the opposite. Let “protect students’ desire to speak” and “test” against each other, so that the uniqueness of writing and writing the general law of opposites, so that “self-cultivation practice” and “teaching”, “training” Opposition, let “writing ” and “reading ” the opposite. If you put them over the top of the special angle, carefully pondering, or have some value. but