《北京档案》去年第4期发表了霍振礼先生的《关于商榷》一文，读后对文中在肯定“商榷”的同时，又对“商榷”提出限制条件而甚感诧异。霍先生认为：“对于某些公开出版的专著，如果该书刚一上市，马上就有商榷性文章出现，就等于给该作者当头一棒”。如果对一本粗制滥造的专著 In the fourth issue of last year, “Beijing Archives” published a paper entitled “Negotiation” by Mr. HUO Zhen-li. After reading it, he was very surprised to find “discussion” at the same time, and at the same time put forward restrictions on “discussion.” Mr.Huo said: “For some published monographs, if the book just listed, there will be a debatable article, it means to the author take the lead.” If a rough shoddy monographs