论文部分内容阅读
最高人民法院于2010年底推出了案例指导制度,对于提高法律的确定性、统一司法标准等具有重大意义,其具体运作机制还有待细化。指导性案例应以审级监督制度的张力赋予事实上的拘束力;应针对法律规则模糊、矛盾、抽象和空白的情况,以解决法律适用问题为标准进行遴选;应归纳出裁判要旨,在统一的平台上及时公布;应建立背离判决的论证机制、上述机制和报告机制以便更新案例。
The Supreme People’s Court launched the case guidance system at the end of 2010, which is of great significance to improving the certainty of the law and unifying the judicial standards. The specific operational mechanism remains to be elaborated. The guiding case should be given the de facto binding force by the tension of the judicial supervision system. The application of the law should be solved according to the obscure, contradictory, abstract and blank legal rules, and the essence of the referee should be summed up. Of the timely publication of the platform; should establish a departure from the verdict mechanism, the mechanism and reporting mechanism in order to update the case.