本论文讨论张忠任教授的价值转形模型和他对白暴力教授价值转形模型的质疑。说明张忠任的模型中缺少一个方程,如果加上这个方程,则根据Frobenius定律,利润率r应该是内生的。由此可见,张忠任的模型是不能成立的。同时,张忠任教授对白暴力教授的价值转形模型的质疑也是值得商榷的。 This dissertation discusses Professor Zhang Zhongren’s value transformation model and his questioning about the value transformation model of the professor of white violence. It shows that there is a missing equation in Zhang’s model. If this equation is added, the profit rate r should be endogenous according to Frobenius’s law. This shows that Zhang Zhong Ren’s model can not be established. In the meantime, Professor Zhang Zhongren’s questioning on the value transformation model of Professor Bai violently is also debatable.