“内煤外热式煤物质分解设备”专利侵权纠纷案件是省、市知识产权管理部门联合审理专利侵权案件的成功典范。其后的行政诉讼案件,是我市办理的第一起专利侵权行政诉讼案件,同时也是陕西省近年来发生的一起典型专利侵权行政诉讼案件。该案作为侵犯专利权典型案例列入全国双打办《2016年中国反侵权假冒年度报告》,同时列入国家知识产权局2016年全国十大专利行政案件。在案件审理的初期(侵权判定阶段),最突出的问题是举证和取证难的问题,同 “Coal thermal coal decomposition equipment ” patent infringement dispute cases is the provincial and municipal intellectual property management department joint trial of patent infringement cases of successful model. The subsequent administrative litigation cases were the first cases of patent infringement litigation handled by the municipality and were also typical cases of patent infringement litigation in Shaanxi Province in recent years. The case as a typical case of infringement of patent rights included in the national doubles “2016 China Anti-Infringement Counterfeiting Annual Report”, at the same time included in the State Intellectual Property Office in 2016 the top ten patent administrative cases. In the early stages of the trial (tort judgment phase), the most prominent issue is the issue of evidence and evidence gathering difficulties,