《〈徐世昌年谱〉及其编者考论》一文,对年谱编者贺培新之生平及其同徐世昌家族关系作了颇为详尽的考证,不过由于作者未参阅徐世昌所撰的《韬养斋日记》,故就《年谱》本身内容的考察略显不足,尚需补正。《韬养斋日记》学术价值很高,它不仅有助于我们进一步了解徐世昌其人其事,更重要的是因其所涉甚广,覆盖了政治、外交、经济、文化等多个领域,通过该日记可以考察晚清民国的社会全貌。 << << Xu Shichang Chronicle> and its editorial review, ’a text on the age of the compilation of He Peixin’s life and its relationship with the family of Xu Shichang made a very detailed research, but because the author did not refer to Xu Shichang’s Tao ting vegetarian diary On the “spectrum” itself slightly less than the inspection, still needs correction. It is not only helpful for us to know more about what happened to Xu Shichang, but more importantly because it covers a very wide range of areas including politics, diplomacy, economy and culture, Through this diary we can examine the social panorama of the Republic of China in the late Qing Dynasty.