王鸣盛《十七史商榷》是清季古史考释名著之一。王氏自称“摩研排缵、二纪余年”,为十七部正史“改伪文、补脱文、去衍文,又举其中典制事迹,诠解蒙滞,审核路驳,以成是书。”王书成就很大,对后学启宜颇多。但王氏为人性格偏激,自以为是,此风羼入著述,因而某些结论不免主观武断,该书卷六十“以女妻姊之孙”条即是一例。 Wang Ming-sheng “A Discussion on the History of the Seventeen History” is one of the well-known works of ancient Chinese history. Wang claimed to be “Mo Yan Pai 缵, two years remaining”, for the seventeen official history “to change the text, off the paper, to Yan Wen, which also cited the deeds of the Code, Interpretation Mongolia stagnation, Book. ”Wang Shucheng great, a lot to start after school. However, Wang’s personal character is extreme and self-righteous. His style is infallible and thus certain conclusions can not but be subjective and arbitrary. The article entitled “Grandson of a Wife and Sister” is an example.