当地时间2月12日,美国旧金山第九巡回上诉法院的三名法官就音乐网站Napster版权纠纷案作出裁决,认为它侵害了各大唱片公司的版权。上诉法院的判决理由是,Napster清楚地知道侵犯版权是怎么一回事,也知道用户们下载的是受版权保护的音乐,他们提供的免费下载 On February 12 local time, three judges of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco ruling on the copyright dispute over the music site Napster that it infringed the copyright of major record companies. The Court of Appeal ruled that Napster knew exactly what the copyright infringement was and that the users downloaded the copyrighted music they downloaded for free