论文部分内容阅读
法院刑事指导案例从裁判要点、相关法条、基本案情到裁判结果、裁判理由应当是一个逻辑严密的统一体,是法官处理类似案件的范本,是刑事司法公正的窗口。其指导功能的充分发挥有赖于以刑事责任量为实体内容的裁判结果的合法性、合理性和说服力,并因此而获得处理类似案件的法官和公众的广泛认同。因此,在刑事指导案例阐述中,刑事责任量的法律根据应全面呈现;作为社会关注度高的死刑、死缓限制减刑、缓刑适用的实质根据应明确认定;同案犯刑事责任量不同的根据也应阐述。
The case of criminal court from the point of referee, the relevant law, the basic merits to the referee, the referee reason should be a logical unity, the judge is a model for handling similar cases, criminal justice is a window. Its guidance function is fully exerted by the legitimacy, rationality and persuasion of the referee’s result with the criminal responsibility as the substantive content and thus widely recognized by judges and the public who handle similar cases. Therefore, the legal basis of the criminal responsibility should be fully presented in the case of criminal guidance; as the death penalty of high social concern, the death penalty should be reduced and the substantive basis for the application of the suspended sentence should be clearly identified; and the basis for the different criminal responsibility of the same crime should also be stated .